Democratic strategist James Carville has expressed concerns regarding the Democratic Party's approach to inclusivity, cautioning that it may hinder Vice President Kamala Harris's election prospects. During a recent podcast interview on Politico’s Playbook Deep Dive, Carville emphasized that while inclusivity can be beneficial, it should not come at the cost of a clear electoral strategy. He stated, “If you want a democracy after the election, you have to have an autocracy before the election,” underscoring the need for decisive leadership during campaigns.
Carville's comments highlighted historical electoral failures of Democratic candidates, such as Michael Dukakis and John Kerry, who he believes were affected by aligning too closely with activist groups. He characterized the current push for an inclusive agenda as counterproductive and suggested that Democrats should delay progressive policies until after the election.
Specifically addressing Harris, Carville urged her to resist activist pressure in the lead-up to the November elections. He advised that discussions about policy should take place only after electoral success has been achieved. He expressed confidence in Harris's potential to win but warned that the party's reliance on progressive language might alienate some voters.
Carville also criticized certain terminologies, such as “communities of color,” arguing that they oversimplify the diverse perspectives within these groups. He further noted that LGBTQ advocacy groups should focus on winning elections rather than pushing an activist agenda during campaigns. Ultimately, he urged the Democratic Party to prioritize effective communication and strategy to secure electoral victories.